Spatial-temporal Evolution and Its Influencing Factors of Tourism Eco-efficiency in China

Chengpeng Lu (Institute of County Economic Development & Rural Revitalization Strategy, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou, 730000, China; School of Economics, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou, 730000, China)
Tianyang Ma (School of Economics, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou, 730000, China)
Zhiliang Liu (School of Economics, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou, 730000, China)

Article ID: 4688


Eco-efficiency is an invaluable indicator for the measurement of the relationship between production activities and environmental depletion. This study measures the tourism eco-efficiency of 30 provinces in China from 2005 to 2020 based on the super-efficiency SBM model, and explores its spatial-temporal evolution characteristics using the kernel density function, standard deviation ellipse, and center of gravity model. Then, the influencing factors of the tourism eco-efficiency in China are analyzed by Tobit regression model. The results show that the tourism eco-efficiency of China is generally fluctuating upwards, but has not yet reached the maximum production possibility frontier. The kernel density curve shows a unimodal-bimodal-unimodal pattern, while the inter-provincial differences have been decreasing and becoming more balanced. The center of gravity of tourism eco-efficiency is located at the junction of Henan and Hubei province and generally moves to the south (slightly to the southwest). Meanwhile, it is revealed that the level of economic development and the tourism eco-efficiency has a significant inverted U-shaped relationship. The level of economic openness, traffic conditions, and tourism eco-efficiency is positively correlated. The environmental regulations and industrial structure have a negative but limited impact on tourism eco-efficiency. Finally, recommendations and suggestions for policy formulation to promote quality and sustainable development of the tourism industry are put forward, such as increasing investment in ecological protection and governance in tourism development, improving capacity-building in allocating green and low-carbon technologies and resources, strengthening tourism infrastructure construction, and enhancing environmental governance systems and mechanisms.


Tourism eco-efficiency; Spatial pattern; Influencing factors; Spatial analysis; China

Full Text:



[1] Liu, Z., Lu, C., Mao, J., et al., 2021. Spatial–Temporal Heterogeneity and the Related Influencing Factors of Tourism Efficiency in China. Sustainability. 13, 5825. DOI:

[2] Geng, Y., Miao, H., Jia, F., et al., 2019. The Visualized Analysis on the Research Cooperation Network of Tourism Research Based on Cite Space. Tourism Research. 11(05), 14-24. DOI:

[3] Ma, J., Miao, H., Wen, S., et al., 2020. Temporal and Spatial Pattern Evolution of Tourism Ecological Security in Gansu Province Based on P-S-R Model. Journal of Hunan University of Science & Technology (Natural Science Edition). 35(03), 118-124. DOI:

[4] Guo, L., Li, C., Peng, H., et al., 2021. Tourism eco-efficiency at the provincial level in China in the context of energy conservation and emission reduction. Progress in Geography. 40(08), 1284-1297. DOI:

[5] Schaltegger, S., Sturm, A., 1990. Okologische rationalitatan-satzpunkte-zur ausgestalung von okologieorientierten management instrumenten. Die Untemehmung. (4), 273-290.

[6] Gossling, S., Petters, P., Gerin, J., 2005. The eco-efficiency of tourism. Ecological Economic. 54(4), 417-434. DOI:

[7] Raymond, C., Booth, A., Louis, B., 2006. Eco-efficiency and SMES in Nova Scotia, Canada. Journal of Cleaner Production. 14(6-7), 542-540. DOI:

[8] Susanne, K., Ariane, W., Mattia, W., 2011. How Can Tourism Use Land More Efficiently? A Model-based Approach to Land-use Efficiency for Tourist Destination. Tourism Management. 32, 629-640. DOI:

[9] Medina, L., Gomez, I., Marrero, S., 2012. Measuring efficiency of sun & beach tourism destinations. Annals of Tourism Research. 39(2), 1248-1251. DOI:

[10] Qiu, X., Fang, Y., Yang, X., 2017. Tourism eco-efficiency measurement, characteristics, and its influence factors in China. Sustainability. 9(9), 16-34. DOI:

[11] Xu, Q., Cheng, H., 2021. Temporal and Spatial Characteristics and Influencing Factors of Coupling Coordination Between China’s Tourism Eco-efficiency and Tourism Green Innovation Efficiency. Journal of Zhongzhou University. 38(02), 33-40. DOI:

[12] Joe, K., Wolfgang, H., 2007. Stated Preferences of Tourists for Eco-efficient Destination Planning Options. Tourism Management. 28, 377-390. DOI:

[13] Tang, R., 2021. Trade facilitation promoted the inbound tourism efficiency in Japan. Tourism Management Perspectives. 38, 100-105. DOI:

[14] Li, Z., 2013. The Use of an Efficiency Evaluation Method in the Tourism Service Industry Based on a Low-carbon Economy Perspective. Tourism Tribune. 28(10), 71-80. DOI:

[15] Yao, Z., Chen, T., Yin, S., et al., 2016. Regional Tourism Eco-Efficiency Model and an Empirical Research of Hainan Province. Scientia Geographica Sinica. 36(03), 417-423. DOI:

[16] Zhong, Y., 2016. Carbon emission measurement and eco-efficiency evaluation of tourism industry. Tourism Tribune. 31(09), 11-12. DOI:

[17] Peng, H., Zhang, J., Han, Y., et al., 2017. Measurement and empirical analysis of eco-efficiency in tourism destinations based on a Slack-based Measure-Data Envelopment Analysis model. Acta Ecologica Sinica. 37(02), 628-638. DOI:

[18] Wang, Z., Zhao, S., 2019. Temporal and Spatial Dynamic Evolution and Influencing Factors of Tourism Efficiency in Hunan Province Based on DEA-Malmquist Model. Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin. 28(08), 1886-1897. DOI:

[19] Chen, L., Wang, W., Wang, B., 2015. Economic Efficiency, Environmental Efficiency and Eco-efficiency of the So-called Two Vertical and Three Horizontal Urbanization Areas: Empirical Analysis Based on HDDF and Co-Plot Method. China Soft Science. (02), 96-109.

[20] Yang, H., Wu, Q., 2017. Study on the eco-efficiency of land use transformation in Jiangsu province from the perspective of carbon remission—Based on the mixed directional distance function. Journal of Natural Resources. 32(10), 1718-1730. DOI:

[21] Lin, X., Guo, Y., Wang, D., 2019. Spatial Evolution and Influencing Factors of Industrial Resource and Environmental Efficiency in China. Scientia Geographica Sinica. 39(3), 377-386. DOI:

[22] Liu, J., Ma, Y., 2017. The Perspective of Tourism Sustainable Development: A Review of Eco-efficiency of Tourism. Tourism Tribune. 32(09), 47-56. DOI:

[23] Peng, J., Chen, H., 2004. A Study on the Efficiency of Star-rated Hotels-A Case Study on the Relative Efficiency of Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou Province. Tourism Tribune. 19(2), 59-62. DOI:

[24] Sun, J., Zhang, J., Zhang, J., et al., 2012. Spatial Characteristics and Optimition Countermeasures of Chinese City Hotel Industry Efficiency. Economic Geography. 32(08), 155-159. DOI:

[25] Zhao, L., Duan, W., 2012. The measurement and analysis of total factor productivity of China’s travel agency industry. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment. 26(8), 180-183. DOI:

[26] Ma, H., Liu, J., Gong, Z., 2019. Carbon Emission and Evolution Mechanism of Tourism Transportation in Shanxi Province. Economic Geography. (4), 223- 231. DOI:

[27] Cao, F., Huang, Z., Wu, J., et al., 2012. The Relationship between Tourism Efficiency Measure and Location Accessibility of Chinese National Scenic Areas. Acta Geographica Sinica. 67(12), 1686-1697.

[28] Fang, Y., Huang, Z., Zhang, H., et al., 2013. The Asynchronous Phenomenon and Relative Efficiency of Tourism Resources in China Based on Panel Data for 31 Provinces from 2001 to 2009. Journal of Resources and Ecology. 38(10), 1754-1764. DOI:

[29] Fang, Y., Huang, Z., Li, D., et al., 2015. The Measurement of Chinese Provincial Tourism Developing Efficiency and Its Spatio-Temporal Evolution. Economic Geography. 35(8), 189-195.

[30] Hu, Y., Mei, L., Chen, Y., 2017. Spatial and Temporal Differentiation Analysis on the Efficiency of the Three Mainstays of Tourism Industry in China. Scientia Geographica Sinica. 37(3), 386-393. DOI:

[31] Liu, Z., Lu, C., Mao, J., et al., 2021. Spatial–Temporal Heterogeneity and the Related Influencing Factors of Tourism Efficiency in China. Sustainability. 13, 5825. DOI:

[32] Ji, S., Xi, Y., Li, F., 2011. Operational Efficiency and Convergence Trend of Chinese Hotel &Tourism Industry. Journal of Shanxi University of Finance and Economics. 33(11), 63-72. DOI:

[33] Liang, M., Yi, T., Bin, L., 2013. Study on the Evolutional Model of Tourism Efficiency Based on DEAMI. Tourism Tribune. 28(5), 53-62. DOI:

[34] Cao, F., Huang, Z., Xu, M., et al., 2015. Spatial-temporal pattern and influencing factors of tourism efficiency and the decomposition efficiency in Chinese scenic areas: Based on the Bootstrap-DEA method. Geographical Research. 34(12), 2395-2408. DOI:

[35] Wang, Y., Sun, C., Jiang, J., 2016. Research on Efficiency and Empirical of Cultural Tourism in Gansu Province Based on Three Stage Data Envelopment Analysis Model. Resource Development & Market. 32(1), 125-128. DOI:

[36] Wang, Z., Liu, Q., 2019. The spatio-temporal evolution of tourism eco-efficiency in the Yangtze River Economic Belt and its interactive response with tourism economy. Journal of Natural Resources. 34(09), 1945-1961. DOI:

[37] Han, Y., Shi, Q., Feng, W., et al., 2019. Temporal spatial differences of tourism industry efficiency and the influencing factors in Shanxi province. Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment. 33(07), 187-194. DOI:

[38] Li, Z., Wang, D., 2020. Temporal and Spatial Differentiation of Tourism Economy-Ecological Efficiency and Its Influencing Factors in Wuling Mountain Area. Economic Geography. 40(06), 233-240. DOI:

[39] Wei, L., Zhang, Y., Li, Q., et al., 2020. Study on Spatial Variation of China’s Territorial Ecological Space Based on Standard Deviation Ellipse. Ecological Economy. 36(07), 176-181.

[40] Deng, H., Lu, L., 2014. The Urban Tourism Efficiencies of Cities in Anhui Province Based on DEA Model. Journal of Natural Resources. 29(02), 313-323. DOI:

[41] Lu, Y., Yuan, P., 2017. Measurement and spatial econometrics analysis of provincial industrial ecological efficiency in China. Resources Science. 39(07), 1326-1337. DOI:

[42] Wu, Y., Song, Y., 2019. Spatio-temporal Pattern Evolution and Driving Factors of Tourism Efficiency in Northeast China. Areal Research and Development. 38(05), 85-90. DOI:

[43] Maddison, D., 2006. Environmental Kuznets Curves: a spatial econometric approach. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management. 51(2), 218-230. DOI:

[44] Yang, R., 2015. Whether Industrial Agglomeration Can Reduce Environmental Pollution or Not. China Population, Resources and Environment. 25(02), 23-29. DOI:

[45] Yuan, Y., Xie, R., 2015. Empirical research on the relationship of industrial agglomeration, technological innovation and environmental pollution. Studies in Science of Science. 33(09), 1340-1347. DOI:

[46] Li, S., Chu, S., Shen, C., 2014. Local government competition, environmental regulation and regional eco-efficiency. The Journal of World. 37(04), 88-110.

[47] Ren, H., Yao, Y., 2016. Effects of Environmental Regulation on Eco-efficiency from the Perspective of Resource Dependence-Based on Super Efficiency SBM Model. Soft Science. 30(06), 35-38. DOI:

[48] Shen, P., Zhu, G., 2011. Resources and environmental problems in the development of tertiary industry in Jiangsu Province. China Population, Resources and Environment. 21(S1), 125-128.

[49] Hong, Z., Wang, L., Zhang, C., 2021. Influencing factors of regional tourism eco-efficiency under the background of green development in the western China. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 41(9), 3512-3524. DOI:

[50] Zhao, L., 2019. Assessing Eco-efficiency of China Tourism Industry with DEA Approach. Journal of Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics (Social Sciences Edition). 32(1), 91-97. DOI:

[51] Guo, L., Li, C., Peng, H., et al., 2021. Tourism eco-efficiency at the provincial level in China in the context of energy conservation and emission reduction. Progress in Geography. 40(08), 1284-1297. DOI:

[52] Lu, J., Liu, Z., Zhang, B., et al., 2020. Ecological Efficiency and Spatial Effects of Tourism Industry in China. Journal of Northeast Forestry University. 48(10), 49-54,60. DOI:

[53] Wang, F., Fang, Y., 2021. Eco-effciency Measurement and Evolution Mechanism of Tourism: A Case Study of Provincial Panel Data in Mainland China. Journal of Huaiyin Teachers College (Natural Sciences Edition), 20(04), 311-318. DOI: 6876.2021.04.005

[54] Wang, S., Qiao, H., Feng, J., et al., 2020. The Spatio-Temporal Evolution of Tourism Eco-Efficiency in the Yellow River Basin and Its Interactive Response with Tourism Economy Development Level. Economic Geography. 40(5), 81-89. DOI:

[55] Li, Z., Wang, D., 2020. Temporal and Spatial Differentiation of Tourism Economy-Ecological Efficiency and Its Influencing Factors in Wuling Mountain Area. Economic Geography. 40(6), 233-240. DOI:



  • There are currently no refbacks.
Copyright © 2022 Chengpeng Lu, Tianyang Ma, Zhiliang Liu Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.